Back to the forum: Nintendo - Super Nintendo Entertainment System

 (no title)
 
Argument: Generic , Reference: 2018 , Closed by: root
TSR @ 2012-08-21 23:19:24

Why is this rom (still) in the No-Intro SNES set?
It's confirmed it has been badly dumped (hirom instead of lorom) and doesn't work anywhere (emu, real hardware), so hmm what's going on? ^^;
C. V. Reynolds @ 2012-09-09 15:49:20

Does a good dump for this game exist yet? If not, No-Intro usually keeps a "best available" dump in the database until a proper one comes around. If the proper one exists somewhere, then please do let me know.
TSR @ 2012-09-09 21:25:46

As far as I know there's no proper dump for this one. And while I kinda understand the logic for keeping it in the set, it's actually forever broken and 100% useless. I thought only working/verified dumps were to be included..
C. V. Reynolds @ 2012-09-11 04:41:12

In my opinion, if it's junk then it's junk, and it shouldn't be in the set. Thus, I agree with you. However, some people believe there may be merit to keeping the portion of data we do have and would object to removing it, and I don't want to step on their toes. I'd get rid of it if it were only up to me, but then I'd also get rid of the extra Mazinger Z dump in the set which I believe to be junk (and from a cart that I don't think truly exists).

I'll label it as a bad dump, regardless.