Board index | NDS forum

 Back to the forum.

Argument: Naming , Reference: generic , Closed by: root
hkA @ 2009-06-20 16:16:55

"Shogi" of the spelling of "将棋" is correct.
This is a spelling as a foreign word to which "日本将棋連盟"(Japan Shogi Association) is decided.

Therefore, it is necessary to change all "Shougi".
kazumi213 @ 2009-06-21 06:45:37

Thank you hkA.

However it is necessary to differentiate between *correct* romanization and *wrong but accepted* romanization. The latter is usually accepted just because is convenient to ensure correct reading by non-japanese people, but that doesn't make the wrong romanization to be legit.

We try to always use *correct* romanization. "Shougi" is the correct romanization according to Hepburn rules.

I would prefer to keep wrong romanization exceptions to a minimum amount, like the Tokyo, Kyoto, Tokaido ones (maybe there are a few more). Starting to use wrong romanization as a general rule just because it is accepted would be a bad decision.